Zum Inhalt
Verein in Gründung
Pilotbetrieb

Diese Plattform befindet sich im Pilotbetrieb. Trotz sorgfältiger Prüfung können Inhalte und Funktionen Fehler enthalten. Bitte überprüfe wichtige Angaben anhand der verlinkten Originalquellen.

SW-Version alpha 0.41
Darstellung: System
Sprache: DE

Overall assessment and recommendation of the Federal Council

Overall assessment and recommendation of the Federal Council

Chapter 5 of the dispatch (pp. 1042-1052) contains the Federal Council's concluding overall assessment and its recommendation to Parliament to approve the package.

Summary

The Federal Council concludes that the negotiating mandate has been fully fulfilled and in parts exceeded. The package offers the most balanced ratio of benefit to policy space that Switzerland could achieve. External studies assess the package positively, and the consultation showed broad support. The Federal Council requests Parliament to approve all four federal decrees.

Fulfilment of the negotiating mandate

The Federal Council evaluates negotiation results against mandate objectives:

Mandate objective Result Assessment
Institutional solution Dispute settlement with arbitration tribunal Fulfilled
Free movement of persons Safeguard clause included Fulfilled
Wage protection Accompanying measures maintained Exceeded
State aid Differentiated solution Fulfilled
Programmes Full retroactive association Exceeded
Swiss contribution CHF 350 m/year (below Norway) Fulfilled
Electricity agreement Universal service protected Fulfilled
Hydropower Concessions not affected Exceeded
Health ECDC/HERA access Fulfilled

Core objective achieved

The package's core objective is achieved: stabilisation and further development of the bilateral path. Specifically:

  • Legal certainty: clear rules for law adoption and dispute settlement
  • Market access: secured and expanded access to the EU internal market
  • Programme participation: full return to EU programmes
  • Policy space: safeguard clause, universal service, hydropower protected

External studies

Several independent studies confirm positive impacts:

Study Institution Key finding
Economic impacts BAK Economics +CHF 4-7 bn GDP long-term
Trade effects KOF ETH Zurich Trade volume stabilisation
Labour market analysis University of Bern Positive employment effects
Research effects SERI Switzerland's return to the top group
Legal opinion FOJ Constitutional

Consultation result

The consultation (summer 2025) revealed broad support:

  • Cantons: large majority positive, some reservations on implementation costs
  • Parties: SP, Centre, FDP, Greens, GLP support; SVP rejects
  • Business: economiesuisse, SGV, SBV predominantly positive
  • Trade unions: SGB, Travail.Suisse support (wage protection secured)
  • Science: swissuniversities, SNSF strongly supportive
  • Civil society: broad support for programmes and health

Most balanced benefit/policy space ratio

The Federal Council emphasises that the package represents the best possible negotiation result:

Benefit:

  • Secured internal market access (CHF 1,800 bn trade volume)
  • Return to EU programmes (research, education, health)
  • Extension to new areas (electricity, food)
  • Legal and planning certainty for the economy

Policy space:

  • Sovereign decision for each law adoption
  • Safeguard clause for free movement of persons
  • Accompanying measures maintained
  • Hydropower concessions protected
  • Universal electricity service guaranteed
  • GMO moratorium maintained

Recommendation of the Federal Council

The Federal Council requests Parliament to:

  1. Approve all four federal decrees (FD1-FD4)
  2. Authorise the Federal Council to ratify the agreements
  3. Approve the necessary framework credits and commitment credits
  4. Take note of the Joint Declaration on the high-level dialogue

Key points

Aspect Detail
Mandate fulfilment Fully fulfilled, in parts exceeded
External studies All positive (BAK, KOF, Uni Bern)
Consultation Broad support
Recommendation Approval of all 4 federal decrees
Core objective Stabilisation of bilateral path achieved
Policy space Safeguard clause, wage protection, hydropower

References

  • Dispatch of the Federal Council on the Switzerland-EU package, chapter 5 (pp. 1042-1052), FedGaz 2025
  • Consultation results report, 2025
  • BAK Economics: economic impacts of Bilateral III, 2025
  • KOF ETH Zurich: trade effects, Working Paper 2025